Skip to Content

Can You Keep Uncrustables in the Fridge?

Can You Keep Uncrustables in the Fridge?

The peanut butter and jelly sandwich is a classic, and Smuckers makes it more convenient than ever to enjoy the hearty treat.

However, when you bring them home from the store, you may be wondering, can you keep Uncrustables in the fridge?

The quick answer is yes, it’s okay to keep Uncrustables in the fridge. However, once thawed, you should only refrigerate them for up to 24 hours. While this might not seem compulsory, eating your snack within 8 to 10 hours of thawing will provide the best taste.

How Are Uncrustables Made?

Before you think about keeping Uncrustables in the fridge, why not spend some time learning to prepare one at home!

The good thing about DIY frozen Uncrustables is that you can choose the bread, jelly, and butter. Plus, homemade snacks are somewhat healthier and budget-friendly.

The few ingredients you require include:

Apply jelly and peanut butter to the bread of your choice. While doing this, leave some room for the sandwich.

Layer the second slice of bread and seal the sandwich by pressing firmly for about 30 seconds. Remove the crusts. That’s it. Refrigerate for about 2 hours.


Are Uncrustables Supposed To Be Frozen?

You might question whether Uncrustables should be frozen. Once you prepare your Uncrustables, you should freeze them for approximately 2 hours.

After freezing them, you can pack them in separate sandwich bags for further storage. Homemade Uncrustables can stay in the freezer for up to one month.

How Long Do Uncrustables Stay Fresh in the Fridge?

If you make your sandwich from refrigerated Uncrustables, ensure you eat them within 24 hours. Doing this guarantees that you get the best flavor from your snacks.

On the other hand, if you will not refrigerate your sandwich, eat them within 6 to 8 hours.

Can You Thaw Uncrustables in the Fridge?

The best taste of Uncrustables is achieved by thawing them at room temperature for 30-60 minutes. Once thawed, you shouldn’t wait for long before consuming your sandwiches.

Eating them within 6 to 8 hours guarantees that you enjoy every bite.

It’s also possible to thaw Uncrustables in the fridge. The best way to do this is by putting them in the fridge early enough. For instance, you can put them in a day before you eat them. This time frame gives them plenty of time to thaw.

Consider replacing the thawed sandwich with another one from the freezer after eating it. This way, you will have one ready to eat on the go.

Uncrustable food refrigerator

Can You Refreeze Uncrustables?

The delicious taste of Uncrustables can leave you thinking about refreezing them for later. Well, it’s not recommended to refreeze them.

Doing this will only create ice crystals, making the bread soggy after thawing. In some cases, the bread can spoil or become freezer burnt.

So, before you thaw your sandwich at room temperature, ensure you can finish it in one sitting. Finishing it quickly prevents wastage or the thought of refreezing Uncrustables for later.

How To Tell if Uncrustables Have Gone Bad?

You may want to know whether Uncrustables have gone bad before eating them. It’s essential to confirm this, especially if you’ve refrigerated them for some time and can’t remember the last time you ate them.

One way to check the Uncrustables is by looking for molds. Check if you can notice any form of discoloration in the bread. You should also check for leaking packs. If you see any of these signs, throw them out.

Another way is to feel the texture of your sandwich. If it’s slimy or stale, this is a sure sign it has gone bad.

If you’re not getting a pleasant aroma from the sandwiches, this is another sign that you should toss them immediately.

uncrustable food

How Can I Eat Uncrustables Right Away?

Snacks are meant to be handy and should provide the convenience you need when you want to grab something and go.

However, for Uncrustables, the quickest way to eat them is by microwaving for 15 seconds on each side. After that, you should allow it to sit for 30 seconds before eating it.

Can You Microwave Frozen Uncrustables?

According to the manufacturer’s recommendation, Uncrustables shouldn’t be microwaved. Microwaving Uncrustables makes the jelly hot and unfit for consumption.

Allowing the sandwich to thaw at room temperature for 30 – 60 minutes is usually recommended.

If you must use the microwave to thaw Uncrustables, do this for only 15 seconds on each side and allow it to cool before eating.

Can You Put Uncrustables in the Toaster?

It’s not advisable to use the toaster or air fryer to prepare Uncrustables.

How Long Do Uncrustables Stay Fresh in the Fridge

Is It Okay To Eat Uncrustables That Have Thawed Overnight?

Yes, it’s perfectly safe to eat Uncrustables that have stayed overnight. Refrigerated Uncrustables can be consumed within 24 hours for the best flavor.

Therefore, you shouldn’t worry that they might have gone bad since they stayed overnight.

Do Uncrustables Go Bad if Not Refrigerated?

While it’s safe to eat refrigerated Uncrustables within 24 hours, they usually lose their flavor if they stay longer. If the Uncrustables have stayed more than 24 hours in the fridge, check for molds or leaking packages.

You should notice a difference in how the Uncrustables look if they have spoiled. In such cases, consider throwing them in the trash.

Are Uncrustables Healthy?

Uncrustables aren’t the healthiest sandwiches. They contain processed vegetable oil and flour and are high in sugar. The good news is that you can prepare homemade Uncrustables and still enjoy them.

The advantage gained here is that you will use whole wheat bread, fruit-based spread, and natural peanut butter.

Are Uncrustables Healthy

Wrapping Up

So, can you keep Uncrustables in the fridge? You now have the answers to make intelligent choices about eating Uncrustables and enjoying every bite.

You noticed that the best way to eat refrigerated Uncrustables is by eating them within 24 hours after removing them from the freezer.

Eating your sandwiches within 24 hours allows you to get the best taste. So, if you’re thinking of snacking the following morning, ensure you remove one from the freezer early.