Skip to Content

How To Thaw Uncrustables Fast (Complete Guide)

How To Thaw Uncrustables Fast (Complete Guide)

Every parent has been there; you’re rushing out the door, and your kid tells you they’re hungry. You’ve had a long day, and you need to feed them something quick that you already know they will like.

Maybe you have a picky eater, and this is one of the few things they will eat.

Uncrustables are fantastic; they’re quick and easy, and you can have one on hand in seconds. They come in several different flavors so that you can satisfy any palette.

How To Thaw Uncrustables Quickly

But sometimes? You don’t get them out of the freezer in time. Which begs the question, how to thaw Uncrustables quickly?

According to Smuckers, you want to take them out thirty to sixty minutes before eating them. They don’t recommend the microwave. But there are other options!

So let’s go through them, shall we?

Thaw Them In the Sun


If you live in a sunny place with nice warm weather, you can speed up the thawing process by a few minutes with the sun alone.

How to thaw Uncrustables quickly in the sun:

  • Leave the Uncrustable in the package.
  • Place it outside in direct sunlight.
  • Turn the Uncrustable over every two to three minutes.
  • Enjoy!

Thaw Them In the Car


Similar to the method where you thaw out an Uncrustable in the sun, you can attempt to hasten to process in your car.

This is an excellent option if you’re currently on the move.

How to thaw Uncrustables quickly in the car:

  • Leave the Uncrustable in the package.
  • Place on your dashboard in direct sun.
  • Flip over if you can, but avoid risking it while your vehicle is in motion.
  • Enjoy!

Thaw Them In Warm Water

This is one that everyone can do; no sun or car is required!

How to thaw Uncrustables quickly in warm water:

  • Leave the Uncrustable in the package.
  • Place the Uncrustable in a bowl.
  • Turn on the water and let it get warm, but not hot.
  • Leave the Uncustable in the water for ten to 15 minutes, occasionally flipping it because the package will float.
  • Remove from water, and enjoy!

Thaw Them In the Microwave?


According to Smuckers, you should refrain from microwaving the Uncrustables to thaw them!

There are a few reasons for this:

  • You can superheat the filling, which is a burning hazard.
  • You can change the texture of the bread, turning it hard and tacky.
  • You may not thaw them evenly, resulting in hot or cold spots throughout the product.

But if you’re absolutely desperate, you can try the following method of how to thaw Uncrustables quickly in the microwave:

  • Remove Uncrustables from the package.
  • Microwave for 15 to 20 seconds, depending on your appliance’s power level.
  • Remove from microwave and allow to sit, hopefully dispersing uneven heating.

Frequently Asked Questions

But we’re not done! You may have some other questions about how to thaw Uncrustables quickly, and we’ll see if we can answer them.

Will Uncrustables thaw in my lunch box?

Yes! This is one of the most popular ways to thaw an Uncrustable sandwich quickly. You can take the product out of the freezer and pack it in your lunch back with your other times.

By the time you get to lunch, your Uncrusable should be defrosted, cold, and delicious!

Why do Uncrustables have to be frozen?

It would be best if you kept Uncrustables in the freezer compartment of your refrigerator until you’re ready to use them. Maintaining them in this state is the best to keep their taste and texture delicious.

If you decide to keep them thawed in the refrigerator, you’ll want to consume them within twenty-four hours; otherwise, the bread will get soggy, and the taste won’t be what you’d expect.

Do you eat Uncrustables hot or cold?

Do you eat uncrustable hot or cold

Uncrustables aren’t meant to be eaten hot, but that doesn’t mean there aren’t people who enjoy them that way.

If you want a toasted Uncrustable, you can let them warm up in a toaster oven until they’re the temperature you enjoy!

Typically, Uncrustables are consumed at a slightly-colder-than-room-temperature coldness. Some people enjoy them frozen, so they’ll never have to worry about how to thaw Uncrustables quickly.

How long do Uncrustables last after you thaw them?

Smuckers states that for Uncrustables sandwiches, you should consume them within six to eight hours of thawing them.

Because of that healthy duration, you’ll have plenty of time to eat your sandwich with lunch if you bring it with you frozen.

Once you pass that period, unfortunately, you’ll need to dispose of your Uncrustable.

What can I eat with my Uncrustable?

The joy of Uncrustables is they’re so simple and delicious that you can have practically anything on the side with them.

Enjoy a variety of fresh fruits and veggies with your sandwich.

grapefruits citric acid

Here are some ideas:

  • Cherry tomatoes
  • Baby carrots
  • Celery
  • Strawberries
  • Blueberries
  • Apple slices
  • Cubed watermelon

What happens to the crust on Uncrustables?

Are they even made with a crust? Smuckers says that they are! And if you’re worried about waste, you can put those worries to rest.

The crust from their Uncrustables is sent to companies that produce animal feed.

What else can I make with my Uncrustables?

If you are wondering if there’s anything else you can do with an Uncrustable, the answer is yes! You can use the chocolate hazelnut flavor to make a killer french toast.

It’s quick and easy and involves switching out plain old bread for an Uncrustable. Easy, right?

Cook Ingredients Flat Lay Spices Oil Stove Pan

All you need is to whisk milk, eggs, cinnamon, and vanilla into a bowl. Dip your Uncrustable into the mixture and then fry them up in a pan with butter, just like you’d do with regular toast.

It’s a delicious alternative and something sure to please the fans of warm Uncrustables. You can try the other flavors of Uncrustables as well!

Is there high fructose corn syrup in my Uncrustables?

Is there high fructose corn syrup in my Uncrustables

As of 2017, Smuckers changed the recipe for Uncrustables, which no longer contains high fructose corn syrup.

Instead, the delicious frozen sandwiches are made with non-GMO sugar for you and your family to enjoy.